| 24/04/27 13:30 | Sutton United- : -Carlisle United | ![]() |
| 17/04/27 16:00 | AFC Fylde- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 10/04/27 16:00 | Solihull Moors- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 03/04/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Worthing | ![]() |
| 29/03/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Yeovil Town | ![]() |
| 26/03/27 16:00 | Southend United- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 20/03/27 13:30 | Scunthorpe United- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 13/03/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Barrow | ![]() |
| 09/03/27 20:45 | Wealdstone- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 06/03/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Gateshead FC | ![]() |
| 27/02/27 16:00 | Hartlepool United- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 23/02/27 20:45 | Eastleigh- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 20/02/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Halifax Town | ![]() |
| 16/02/27 20:45 | Sutton United- : -Tamworth | ![]() |
| 13/02/27 16:00 | Forest Green Rovers- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 06/02/27 16:00 | Boston United- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 30/01/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Woking | ![]() |
| 26/01/27 20:45 | Sutton United- : -AFC Hornchurch | ![]() |
| 23/01/27 16:00 | Altrincham- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 08/01/27 20:45 | Aldershot Town- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 02/01/27 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Harrogate Town | ![]() |
| 28/12/26 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Southend United | ![]() |
| 26/12/26 16:00 | Yeovil Town- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 19/12/26 13:30 | Sutton United- : -Kidderminster Harriers | ![]() |
| 08/12/26 20:00 | Boreham Wood- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 05/12/26 16:00 | Sutton United- : -AFC Fylde | ![]() |
| 28/11/26 16:00 | Carlisle United- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 24/11/26 20:45 | AFC Hornchurch- : -Sutton United | ![]() |
| 21/11/26 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Boston United | ![]() |
| 14/11/26 16:00 | Sutton United- : -Solihull Moors | ![]() |
| 03/11/26 20:00 | Sutton United3 : 1Southampton U21 |
| 31/10/26 16:00 | Worthing0 : 3Sutton United |
| 28/10/26 20:45 | Sutton United2 : 0Aldershot Town |
| 24/10/26 13:30 | Harrogate Town3 : 1Sutton United |
| 17/10/26 16:00 | Sutton United1 : 0Truro City FC |
| 13/10/26 20:00 | Sutton United3 : 2West Bromwich U21 |
| 09/10/26 20:45 | Sutton United0 : 2Boreham Wood |
| 03/10/26 16:00 | Kidderminster Harriers1 : 1Sutton United |
| 30/09/26 20:45 | Tamworth2 : 0Sutton United |
| 26/09/26 16:00 | Sutton United3 : 3Forest Green Rovers |
| 19/09/26 16:00 | Halifax Town1 : 1Sutton United |
| 15/09/26 20:45 | Sutton United2 : 1Eastleigh |
| 12/09/26 16:00 | Sutton United0 : 2Scunthorpe United |
| 08/09/26 20:00 | Sutton United6 : 7Birmingham U-21 |
| 05/09/26 16:00 | Barrow3 : 0Sutton United |
| 31/08/26 16:00 | Sutton United0 : 2Wealdstone |
| 28/08/26 20:45 | Gateshead FC0 : 1Sutton United |
| 22/08/26 13:30 | Sutton United2 : 1Hartlepool United |
| 15/08/26 16:00 | Sutton United1 : 0Altrincham |
| 08/08/26 16:00 | Woking0 : 3Sutton United |