| 20/07/26 01:00 | Flint City Bucks2 : 1Steel City |
| 17/07/26 22:00 | Steel City1 : 0Northern Indiana |
| 17/07/26 22:00 | Steel City1 : 0Northern Indiana |
| 12/07/26 01:00 | Lorain County Leviathan0 : 1Steel City |
| 09/07/26 00:00 | Cleveland Force0 : 1Steel City |
| 02/07/26 00:00 | Steel City3 : 1Cleveland Force |
| 27/06/26 23:00 | FC Buffalo1 : 1Steel City |
| 25/06/26 01:00 | Erie Sports Center1 : 3Steel City |
| 21/06/26 01:00 | Akron City0 : 1Steel City |
| 13/06/26 21:00 | Steel City4 : 0Erie Sports Center |
| 11/06/26 00:00 | Steel City0 : 0Pittsburgh Riverhounds II |
| 06/06/26 21:00 | Steel City3 : 0FC Buffalo |
| 30/05/26 21:00 | Steel City1 : 0Akron City |
| 28/05/26 01:00 | Pittsburgh Riverhounds II0 : 2Steel City |
| 26/03/26 00:00 | Pittsburgh Riverhounds2 : 1Steel City |
| 19/07/25 01:30 | Flint City Bucks4 : 3Steel City |
| 13/07/25 21:00 | Cleveland Force1 : 3Steel City |
| 07/07/25 01:00 | Steel City2 : 1Toledo Villa |
| 03/07/25 01:00 | Steel City0 : 0FC Buffalo |
| 29/06/25 21:00 | Steel City1 : 1Akron City |
| 26/06/25 01:00 | FC Buffalo1 : 4Steel City |
| 20/06/25 01:30 | Toledo Villa2 : 3Steel City |
| 06/06/25 01:00 | Steel City2 : 0Cleveland Force |
| 29/05/25 01:00 | Toledo Villa2 : 1Steel City |
| 24/05/25 22:00 | Erie Sports Center1 : 2Steel City |
| 22/05/25 01:00 | Steel City2 : 1FC Buffalo |
| 18/05/25 01:00 | Akron City2 : 2Steel City |
| 22/03/24 00:00 | Steel City0 : 1Michigan Stars |