| 25/10/26 01:35 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 2Westchester |
| 22/10/26 00:35 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 3Naples |
| 18/10/26 01:35 | Fort Wayne1 : 3Sarasota Paradise |
| 11/10/26 01:35 | Sarasota Paradise3 : 2Richmond Kickers |
| 04/10/26 01:35 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 3Charlotte Independence |
| 26/09/26 23:00 | Portland Hearts of Pine1 : 4Sarasota Paradise |
| 20/09/26 01:35 | Sarasota Paradise6 : 0Greenville Triumph |
| 13/09/26 00:00 | Forward Madison1 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 06/09/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 1Spokane Velocity |
| 03/09/26 01:30 | New York Cosmos1 : 2Sarasota Paradise |
| 23/08/26 01:00 | Union Omaha1 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 20/08/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise3 : 2Chattanooga Red Wolves |
| 16/08/26 01:00 | Charlotte Independence3 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 09/08/26 01:30 | One Knoxville2 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 30/07/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 2Portland Hearts of Pine |
| 12/07/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise0 : 5Miami |
| 09/07/26 01:00 | Greenville Triumph0 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 04/07/26 01:30 | Richmond Kickers0 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 21/06/26 02:30 | Corpus Christi FC4 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 14/06/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 0Union Omaha |
| 11/06/26 05:00 | AV Alta3 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 07/06/26 01:30 | Naples0 : 2Sarasota Paradise |
| 31/05/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 1New York Cosmos |
| 28/05/26 03:00 | AC Boise0 : 2Sarasota Paradise |
| 25/05/26 01:00 | Spokane Velocity1 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 17/05/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 2AV Alta |
| 14/05/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise0 : 2Sporting Jax |
| 09/05/26 21:00 | Chattanooga Red Wolves4 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 03/05/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 3Forward Madison |
| 26/04/26 01:30 | Tampa Bay Rowdies2 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 23/04/26 00:30 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 1Corpus Christi FC |
| 12/04/26 01:05 | Naples2 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 09/04/26 01:05 | Westchester2 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 05/04/26 01:35 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 2One Knoxville |
| 29/03/26 00:35 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 0Portland Hearts of Pine |
| 15/03/26 00:35 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 2Fort Wayne |
| 08/03/26 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise0 : 1AC Boise |
| 22/02/26 01:00 | Tampa Bay Rowdies1 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 07/02/26 22:00 | Rhode Island2 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 21/01/26 19:00 | New York Red Bulls1 : 3Sarasota Paradise |
| 17/01/26 18:00 | New England Revolution6 : 0Sarasota Paradise |
| 21/07/25 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 2Fort Lauderdale Strikers |
| 19/07/25 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise2 : 0Sporting Jax |
| 13/07/25 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise3 : 0Miami City |
| 06/07/25 00:00 | Miami AC0 : 16Sarasota Paradise |
| 03/07/25 01:00 | St. Petersburg FC1 : 1Sarasota Paradise |
| 29/06/25 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise3 : 0Weston |
| 22/06/25 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise1 : 0Kings Hammer Sun City |
| 19/06/25 01:30 | Sarasota Paradise3 : 0Fort Lauderdale Strikers |
| 12/06/25 01:30 | Miami City4 : 2Sarasota Paradise |